France has nearly one million over-indebted households. A phenomenon that the government is unable to control. Explanations. Compared to other countries, French law is more protective for borrowers, especially on revolving loans or mortgages.
Indomitable scourge. Over-indebtedness in France grew visibly despite the maelstrom came the legislative framework in recent years. According to the French Federation of Associations Cresus (Regional Chamber of social debt), more than 900,000 households were in serious debt in late 2010. A number expected to reach one million by the end of the year. In the first half 2011, they were some 106 000 to file an application to the debt commission, or 12% more than last year."A record of debt is registered in France every three minutes," says the report, released Friday by the Tribune. On average, this issue amounts to 45,000 euros depending on the Bank of France, an amount much higher than in other European countries. How to explain this phenomenon, however, that policies seem to want to halt at all costs? Explanations.
Why does the debt still rising?
The crisis, it still. The causes of debt are found especially the deterioration of the purchasing power of households, followed far behind by the accidents of life (divorce etc). Thus, according to the Cresus, cash loans for paying the expenses of daily living 87% of over-indebtedness. Economist Eric Heyer L'OFCE said this: "In France, people who have lost their jobs have not been able to find work.Once their benefits are lost, they fell into poverty until they can not repay their loans. "Clearly, as the country slowly reconnect and businesses with growth, the unemployed were out of employment and poverty gleans from field. This is particularly the case among the middle classes who seem more vulnerable: "They have a very heavy burden. Their kids do not have a scholarship. We must now borrow for education in all schools. It costs money. So they must have access to credit, but very often when they have taken loans and are unable to repay, they réempruntent. "Says the site of Europe 1, Jean-Louis Kiehl, president of the Federation Cresus associations. A situation more delicate than the middle classes generally have no access to welfare or housing benefits.Other at-risk population, the elderly, "who come to the aid of their children, borrow, take credit for helping kids. (…) And it creates dramas that are tragic," complained Jean-Louis Kiehl yet.
There is no legislation that regulates the debt overhang?
Indeed, this is a problem that governments are committed to resolve. Lagarde Law Reform consumer credit is the latest example. Specifically, the law's purpose is to enhance consumer protection by increasing the obligations of banks. Pre-contractual information clear and legible, the prohibition of misleading advertising too good, the evaluation of the creditworthiness of the borrower … since May 1, credit institutions can not afford anything and everything in the granting of credit.These also are exposed to significant fines if they do not respect their commitments. For Cresus However, this reform would be inadequate, too complicated and in some ways impractical. The regional network calls, in particular to end the system of assessing creditworthiness based on the declarative. It also calls for the government to create a positive file listing all the loans taken by individuals, prior to the presidential election. Today Lagarde Law only stipulates the obligation for banks to check the file with payment before granting a loan
What to do?
Strengthen legislation again and again … However, if the trend is great to attack only credit institutions to explain these failures, you have to keep right.Compared to other countries already, the French legislation is much more protective for borrowers, especially on revolving credit or mortgage, very few practiced by banks. In addition, some situations are inherently impossible to predict. This applies to the person who borrows money from a funding agency, loses his job, and finds himself in a few months unable to repay his or her loans.
Should we worry about this?
Difficult to answer that question without falling into schizophrenia. From a purely macroeconomic perspective, the level of indebtedness is not indicative of the average debt of the French, in fact much lower than in other European countries (70% against 83% for the euro area).But this is not necessarily a good thing when the economy is doing well: a high debt ratio helps because consumption and therefore growth. The right slider is finally a high level of debt but which allows borrowers to remain solvent. Finally, the tragedy of over-indebtedness can be understood as follows: "It is proof that the country become poor, and structural unemployment (long term) may be moving beyond cyclical unemployment. It is in that These figures are devastating. Redistribution of wealth does not work, "concludes Eric Heyer.